The Secret : 2007-02-18
Comments: 9  |  Permalink  |  View all rants
A new health-and-wealth craze called "The Secret" seems to be gaining popularity. I recently received this email:
Do you have any comments on this latest craze, "the secret." It was on Oprah Winfrey a week ago and it seems to becoming very popular, even among christians. I would like any feedback you could give me.
Thank you,
Cindy
I did a little checking and replied:
Hi Cindy,

The movie is the basic "power of positive thinking" New Agey sort of junk that's popular on Oprah. Rather than relying on God, you rely on your own positive thoughts to create your own reality. Any Christians who fall for this simply don't know much about Biblical teaching, since a Christian worldview has nothing in common with "the secret."

Thanks for taking the time to write.
Anyone out there familiar with "The Secret"?



9 comments for The Secret

1. Ace Email Web 2007-02-28  9:43am

Hi Randy - Been hearing more and more about this newest craze. I came across this earlier today and thought it was on target:

http://stackblog.wordpress.com/2007/02/21/oprahs-secret-new-old-good-bad/


2. Randy Email Web 2007-02-28  2:08pm

Ace, thanks for the link. Stackhouse does a good job of examining "The Secret."


3. Randy Brandt Email Web 2007-03-05  8:13am

James White takes a good look at The Secret.


4. Julie Pence Email Web 2007-03-13  3:03pm

Hi, and thank you all for the information you have shared. I checked out Stackhouse's writing on "The Secret", as well as James White's. Well written. I would also like to add the following site to check out, written by Marcia Montenegro, who came out of the New Age movement into Christianity: http://cana.userworld.com/cana_Secret.html . I seem to be the one out, amongst my nonChristian coworkers, but I would say to steer clear of this craze. Of course, my coworkers think I am not 'thinking positively', to say such a thing. But we have joy and comfort and hope in Jesus Christ for which we need no further secret.


5. Randy Brandt Email Web 2007-03-14  1:00pm

Thanks for posting, Julie. I'll check out the link you gave.


6. Matt P. Email Web 2007-03-27  8:48pm

Al Mohler has also written about "The Secret" on his blog.


7. Randy Brandt Email Web 2007-03-28  7:33am

Thanks, Matt. Here's the link. Mohler concludes, "There is no real secret to The Secret. It is just the same old self-worship packaged for a new generation."

He includes a link to an audio talk on the subject, as well as another article.


8. Matt P. Email Web 2007-03-28  4:48pm

Randy, you quote Al Mohler as saying "It is just the same old self-worship packaged for a new generation." Are you sure he wasn't referring to the Emerging Church? You know, the old kind of non-Christians?


9. Randy Brandt Email Web 2007-03-29  6:43am

Matt, I guess that quote applies to a lot of topics. :-)


Comment on The Secret










You must enter a seven (this reduces automated comment spam):

Welcome!
Register
Franklin Graham Disappoints Again: Rant
Dear sir, I am not defending Mr. Graham; the Lord is able to make him stand or fall, and Mr. Graham will answer to His...
by Heath McAnally  2010-08-06  6:29pm
Shame on Liberty U!: Rant
Fascinating breaking news, starrstruck! I knew there was a way for Liberty to spin it.
by Randy  2010-06-21  4:09pm
The Courage to Be Protestant: Non-Fiction
Here is another review by someone who shares your insistence on inerrancy and penal substitution. Can you say...
by Henry  2008-06-11  6:05pm
The Shack: Fiction
I want to pass along my recent review of ‘The Shack’. This review deals specifically with the issue of Christian...
by Mark  2010-07-21  11:28am
Unless otherwise noted, all contents Copyright 2001-2010 Randy Brandt